When Hayes cautiously questioned these highly unusual catalog orders, Delilah smoothly replied that God was preparing her family for a “special calling” that required absolute self-sufficiency.
Behind the closed doors of the McKenna farm, that “special calling” was taking a monstrous shape. Years later, when investigators finally breached the farmhouse, they discovered Delilah’s private journals hidden beneath the floorboards of her bedroom. These diaries, dating back to 1887, reveal a woman who had thoroughly convinced herself that a divine mandate justified absolute atrocity. Delilah wrote extensively about her oldest son, Thomas, viewing him not as a child, but as an instrument through which she would establish a pure bloodline.
Her erratic handwriting detailed the systematic, chilling modifications she was making to the family barn. She was not preparing stalls for horses or cattle; she was constructing a human breeding facility. Her notes contained meticulous diagrams for locking mechanisms, fertility cycle calculations, and chilling instructions on how to properly restrain unwilling participants.
The community’s absolute final glimpse of the McKenna sons as free individuals occurred during a brutal blizzard in the winter of 1889. The Fletcher family, stranded in the blinding snow, sought refuge at the McKenna property. As they approached the farmhouse, they heard inexplicable sounds coming from the barn—the unmistakable rattling of heavy chains mixed with muffled cries. Before they could investigate, Delilah met them on the porch, brandishing a loaded shotgun. She coldly claimed her boys were suffering from a highly contagious fever and forced the terrified neighbors off her land.
By 1890, the McKenna farm had morphed into an impenetrable fortress. Delilah’s personal ledger, later seized by authorities, marked September 15, 1890, as the official beginning of her reign of terror. On this date, she recorded in horrific, clinical detail the first forced breeding between her eldest son, Thomas, and a young woman she had lured to the farm under false pretenses. Delilah deemed this the “blessed beginning of God’s pure lineage.”
What followed was a decade of unchecked, systematic horrors. Sheriff William Crawford, the local lawman, first began to suspect something was deeply wrong in late 1895. In the span of just six months, three healthy, young women from impoverished families vanished without a trace while traveling the mountain roads near Milbrook Hollow. One victim, nineteen-year-old Martha Henderson, disappeared while riding to visit relatives. Her horse was found wandering aimlessly near the McKenna property line.
When Crawford questioned Delilah, her composure was unnervingly perfect. She claimed to have seen nothing. But the seasoned sheriff’s instincts were screaming. He began mapping the disappearances and realized that the victims shared specific characteristics that made them vulnerable, and all their paths mysteriously intersected near the McKenna farm.
In the spring of 1896, Crawford received an anonymous letter delivered under the cover of darkness. The terrified author, later revealed to be neighbor Samuel Briggs, claimed that on certain nights, aligning perfectly with the lunar cycle, horrifying screams could be heard echoing from the McKenna barn. Briggs described the sounds as a mixture of women crying for their lives and chains dragging across heavy wooden floorboards.
continued on next page
For complete cooking times, go to the next page or click the Open button (>), and don't forget to SHARE with your Facebook friends.
